Help to Buy and Shared Ownership: Are They Worth It?

Help to Buy and Shared Ownership are two government schemes designed to make homeownership more affordable, mainly for first-time buyers. But "affordable" is relative - and the schemes come with hidden costs that can make them more expensive than a traditional mortgage. This guide breaks down how they work, what they really cost, and whether they're worth it for your situation.
What is Shared Ownership?
Shared Ownership is a scheme where you buy a share of a property - usually 25% to 75%, and as little as 10% on some homes - and pay rent to the landlord on the rest. The idea sounds simple: own a portion, save money on the deposit, climb the property ladder faster. The reality is more complicated.
Here's how it works. You buy your share (let's say 40%) with a mortgage or savings. You pay a mortgage on that 40%. You then pay rent on the 60% owned by the landlord (usually a housing association). So you're making two monthly payments: a mortgage payment (which builds equity) and a rent payment (which doesn't). You'll usually pay ground rent and service charges too.
On a £250,000 property at 40% ownership, you'd put down a 5-10% deposit on your £100,000 share (so £5,000-£10,000 in cash). You'd then get a mortgage for the remaining £90,000-£95,000. But you'd also pay monthly rent on the £150,000 you don't own. On new-build homes the rent limit is 3% a year of the landlord's share, and most landlords charge 2.75%. So on a £250,000 flat, that's about £344/month in rent on top of your mortgage.
In England, you can usually apply if your household income is £80,000 a year or less (£90,000 in London) and you're a first-time buyer, though there are exceptions, such as existing shared owners who want to move.
The key feature is "staircasing" - over time, you can buy additional shares in the property, and the more you own, the less rent you pay. Many people eventually buy the remaining share and become full owners. But staircasing isn't free: you pay a surveyor's fee (£250-£500), a mortgage arrangement fee for the new mortgage, and potentially stamp duty on the additional share.
The rules above are for England; Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have different rules. You can search for schemes on the government's dedicated site.
The Help to Buy Timeline
Help to Buy: Equity Loan is closed: you can no longer apply for it for properties in England. But it's worth understanding what it did, because many buyers still hold Help to Buy loans, and the legacy questions remain.
Help to Buy: Equity Loan gave buyers of new-build homes a government loan towards the price, for example 20%. You'd put down a deposit, the government lent its share, and you'd mortgage the rest. You don't pay interest for the first 5 years. In the sixth year interest is charged at 1.75%, and the rate rises every April (by CPI plus 2% on the later scheme, or RPI plus 1% on loans from the 2013 to 2021 scheme). The loan is normally due at the end of a 25-year term, or earlier if you sell.
The scheme was useful if you couldn't save a 20% deposit but could get a mortgage on 75% LTV. On a £250,000 property, a 20% Help to Buy loan meant you only needed £12,500 cash (5%) instead of £50,000 (20%). That was real money for first-time buyers in expensive areas.
But it has closed, and Shared Ownership remains available.
The True Cost of Shared Ownership
The mortgage part of Shared Ownership is straightforward - it's like any other mortgage. What catches people out is everything else.
Rent on the share you don't own. This is the biggest hidden cost. On the earlier £250,000 example at 40% ownership, you're paying roughly £344/month in rent on the housing association's 60% share. Over 20 years, that's £82,560 even if the rent never rose. It's not building equity; it's gone. And the rent can't go down: the landlord usually reviews it once a year, and increases are capped in line with inflation (RPI plus up to 0.5%, or CPI plus 1% on some leases signed from 12 October 2023).
Service charges. You share responsibility for building maintenance. The housing association will charge you a service charge for your share of repairs, insurance, and management. Expect £100-£300/month depending on the building condition and location.
Staircasing costs. When you buy additional shares, you don't just pay the new purchase price. You pay:
- A new mortgage arrangement fee (typically £500-£2,000 for the additional mortgage)
- A surveyor's fee (£250-£500)
- Solicitor's fees (£400-£800)
- Stamp duty on the additional share (if it crosses the threshold)
On a £250,000 property, buying a 15% additional share (from 40% to 55%) might cost you an extra £37,500 in property price - plus roughly £1,150-£3,300 in the fees above, and any stamp duty. Many people underestimate these costs.
Ground rent (on leasehold shares). All Shared Ownership homes, houses and flats, are leasehold. You own a long lease (typically 125 years), but you don't own the land. This opens up other costs:
- Ground rent (usually fixed or rising annually, can be £100-£300/year)
- Your contribution to buildings insurance
- Potential issues when the lease gets short (below 80 years) - remortgaging becomes harder and more expensive
Difficulty selling. Shared Ownership properties can be harder to sell than traditional owner-occupied homes. Fewer buyers want them, and lenders are pickier about lending on them. You might find yourself needing to drop the price or wait longer to sell.
Restrictions. The housing association has rules. You usually can't let the property out (rent it to tenants) without their consent. You can't renovate without approval. Remortgaging may need the housing association's agreement too. This lack of control frustrates many owners.
Shared Ownership vs Building a Deposit for a Traditional Mortgage
Let's compare two paths using example numbers, assuming house prices rise 2% a year.
Scenario A: Shared Ownership You buy a £250,000 flat at 40% ownership. You put down £10,000 (10% of your share). You get a mortgage for £90,000 at 5.2% over 25 years = £537/month. Rent on the 60% you don't own at 2.75% p.a. = £344/month. Service charge = £150/month. Total monthly cost = £1,031/month.
After 10 years, you've paid £123,720 in total (mortgage + rent + service charge), assuming none of the costs rose. You've paid the mortgage down to roughly £67,000, so about £23,000 of your payments went into equity. At 2% a year the property is worth about £304,700, so your 40% share is worth about £121,900. But you've spent over £123,000 in cash on top of your deposit. If you sold today, you'd have little gain after estate agent fees and closing costs.
Scenario B: Traditional Mortgage (waiting for deposit) You rent for 5 years while saving. On the same flat, renting costs £1,100/month = £66,000 over 5 years. That's more than Scenario A would have cost over the same 5 years (£61,860). Meanwhile house prices have risen; at 2% a year the flat is now about £276,000. Suppose you've saved a £50,000 deposit by then (18%) and get a mortgage for £226,000 at 4.9% over 25 years = £1,308/month.
Now you own 100% of the property. After another 10 years (15 total from the start), you've paid about £156,960 in mortgage payments. The property is worth about £336,000 at the same 2% growth. You own all of it. After estate agent and closing costs, you've got significant equity.
The numbers aren't straightforward because:
- House prices might not rise at 2% per year (they might rise faster or slower)
- You might not save as disciplined as planned
- Interest rates change
- Shared Ownership rent rises each year it's reviewed and never falls
Use our rent vs buy calculator to model your specific situation with realistic assumptions.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Underestimating the cost of staircasing. Many Shared Ownership buyers plan to staircase to 100% ownership within 5-10 years. They forget that staircasing isn't just buying the remaining share at current market value - it's paying mortgage arrangement fees, surveyors, solicitors, and potentially stamp duty. Using the fee ranges above, budget roughly £1,150-£3,300 in fees for each staircasing transaction, plus any stamp duty. Some people spend more on fees than they anticipated.
Not understanding rent escalation. The housing association's rent increase is typically linked to RPI (Retail Prices Index) or CPI inflation. If inflation rises, so does your rent. Over 20 years, this can compound significantly. A £300/month rent would become about £542/month if it rose 3% every year. Factor this into your long-term budget.
Forgetting about your mortgage affordability. Because Shared Ownership requires a smaller deposit, it's tempting to stretch for a more expensive property. But you're still responsible for the mortgage and rent. If your mortgage is 4.5x your salary, and you also have £300+ in monthly rent, you're on a tight budget. A single rate rise or job disruption could hurt.
Assuming the housing association is a landlord like any other. They're not. They have restrictions, approval requirements, and different incentives. Some are better managed than others. Check reviews of the specific housing association managing your property before buying.
Not getting professional advice. Shared Ownership legal documents are complex. The mortgage terms interact with the lease terms in subtle ways. A conveyancer or solicitor experienced in Shared Ownership (not just traditional mortgages) is worth the £500-£800 fee. They'll spot issues you'd otherwise miss.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Shared Ownership cheaper than renting? It depends on your rent and the property. On the £250,000 example (40% ownership), you'd pay £1,031/month in ownership costs (mortgage + rent + service charge) vs. £1,100-£1,200 for renting a similar property. So yes, it's a bit cheaper. But you're also responsible for repairs, insurance, and maintaining the property. The financial advantage is marginal, and you're taking on more responsibility.
Can I get a mortgage to buy a Shared Ownership property? Yes, but fewer lenders offer them. Your deposit is usually 5-10% of the share you're buying, and the mortgage covers the rest of your share. You may pay a slightly higher rate (0.1-0.5% premium) because of the extra risk to the lender. Check with a broker - some lenders specialise in Shared Ownership.
What happens if I want to sell my Shared Ownership home? If you own less than 100%, you must tell your landlord, who then has a "nomination period" of 4, 8 or 12 weeks (depending on your lease) to find a buyer. The sale price will be no more than the current market value of your share, based on a valuation by a RICS-registered surveyor. If the landlord doesn't find a buyer in time, you can sell your share yourself on the open market. If you own 100%, you can usually sell on the open market straight away. A smaller pool of buyers can still make selling slower or require a lower price.
Can I do staircasing if I've had a pay cut or job loss? Often not, if you need to borrow. Staircasing usually requires a new or bigger mortgage, and you need to pass the lender's affordability checks just like for the original purchase. If your income has dropped or credit has suffered, you may not qualify. Many people plan to staircase on a schedule and then can't because their circumstances change.
Is Shared Ownership a good idea if I plan to stay 30+ years? Probably not. If you're buying a home you plan to stay in until retirement, a traditional mortgage at 85-90% LTV (once you've saved a larger deposit) is better. You'll own 100% of the property, have no rent to pay, and have more control. The benefit of Shared Ownership is getting onto the property ladder faster when you're young. If you can afford to wait and save, do.
What if the property drops in value? You're liable for negative equity (owing more than the property is worth) on your share, just like with a traditional mortgage. But at 40% ownership the housing association owns the majority, so they have a bigger exposure. Some housing associations have been forgiving about this; others haven't. Check how the association handled the 2008 financial crisis - that's a clue to their behavior in downturns.
Can I remortgage my Shared Ownership property to a better rate? Yes, but the housing association may need to approve it, and that can take time (4-8 weeks). You can't simply switch lenders as quickly as with a traditional mortgage. Factor in this delay if rates are falling and you want to lock in quickly.
Is Shared Ownership worth it if I could buy with a 15% deposit? If you can save a 15% deposit for a traditional mortgage, it's usually better to do that. An 85% LTV mortgage at 5.2% over 25 years (£250,000 property = £212,500 mortgage) costs £1,267/month. Shared Ownership at 40% costs £537 mortgage + £344 rent + £150 service charge = £1,031/month. Shared Ownership looks cheaper, but you don't own the property, rent will rise, and you're paying all the service charge costs. After 10 years, the traditional mortgage will have been paid down significantly; Shared Ownership will have cost you more. The math favors the traditional route if you can access it.
Next Steps
Shared Ownership makes sense if:
- You're a first-time buyer who can't save a 15%+ deposit
- The property is in an area where you plan to stay 5-10+ years
- You understand and accept the rent, service charges, and staircasing costs
- You've researched the specific housing association and their reputation
If none of these apply, explore alternatives. If you're comparing Shared Ownership with renting or a traditional mortgage, use our mortgage calculator to model the numbers. Try different scenarios: different deposit amounts, different interest rates, different timeframes. The decision often comes down to your specific numbers and plans, not the scheme's promise alone.