Investment & Retirement

What Is Rebalancing and How Often Should You Do It?

1 May 2025|SimpleCalc|8 min read
Portfolio pie chart drifting and being rebalanced

Rebalancing should be on your investment to-do list, yet many investors do it sporadically or not at all. Here's what happens: you start with a target portfolio - say 60% equities and 40% bonds. If equities grow faster, a few years later you could be at 70% equities and 30% bonds. You've accidentally taken more risk than you intended. Rebalancing corrects this drift, and the question everyone asks is: how often should you do it? This guide answers that with worked numbers and a practical framework.

What Is Portfolio Rebalancing?

Rebalancing is the process of adjusting your portfolio back to your target allocation. It sounds simple, but it's worth understanding how it works.

Imagine you build a three-fund portfolio with three funds: 40% UK equities, 35% global equities, 25% bonds. Over time, each grows at a different rate. Say UK equities return 8% one year, global equities 10% and bonds 3%. After 12 months, your allocation has drifted to about 40.2% UK, 35.8% global, 24.0% bonds. That's a small shift, but repeat it for a few years and your portfolio carries more stock risk than you planned.

Rebalancing means selling some winners (equities) and buying more of the laggards (bonds). You're doing the opposite of what feels natural: trimming your best performers. Understanding your risk tolerance means committing to a target allocation and sticking to it - even when one asset class outperforms.

Why Your Portfolio Drifts—And Why It Matters

Let me show you with numbers. Take a £50,000 portfolio split 60% equities (£30,000) and 40% bonds (£20,000), with equities growing 10% a year and bonds 3% a year.

Year 1:

  • Equities grow 10% → £33,000
  • Bonds grow 3% → £20,600
  • New allocation: 61.6% equities, 38.4% bonds ✓ (still close)

Year 3 (with compounding):

  • Equities grow to ~£39,930
  • Bonds grow to ~£21,850
  • New allocation: 64.6% equities, 35.4% bonds (creeping up)

Year 5:

  • Equities grow to ~£48,300
  • Bonds grow to ~£23,190
  • New allocation: 67.6% equities, 32.4% bonds (notably drifted)

At these growth rates the portfolio passes 70% equities in year 7. Whenever equities grow faster than bonds, as here, your portfolio gradually becomes more stock-heavy than intended. If you built a 60/40 split for a specific balance of growth and stability, that balance erodes.

The real cost of drift: When a market crash hits and equities drop 20%, a 67.6% stock allocation loses about 13.5% of the portfolio, against 12% at 60%. Worse, panic might make you sell. If you'd rebalanced two years earlier, you'd have a more stable portfolio and less urge to make emotional decisions. Rebalancing also means you buy bonds when they're cheap relative to stocks, rather than expensive, and buy stocks after they've fallen.

The main aim of rebalancing is to keep your risk where you chose to put it, not to boost returns. Over long periods it can mean slightly lower returns than letting equities run, in exchange for a smoother ride.

How Often Should You Rebalance?

Here's the honest answer: there's no single right answer. The best frequency depends on your circumstances.

Annual rebalancing is the most common and easiest approach. Once a year (your birthday, New Year, tax year end), run the numbers, see how far you've drifted, and rebalance. This hits the sweet spot: regular enough to prevent significant drift, infrequent enough to avoid excessive trading costs.

Quarterly rebalancing can suit a larger portfolio where trading costs matter less. It keeps your allocation tighter to your target, but any benefit over annual rebalancing is usually small and can be wiped out by trading costs if you're not careful.

Threshold-based rebalancing - acting when an asset class drifts more than 5 percentage points from its target - is more flexible. Rather than a fixed calendar, you rebalance when your allocation actually wanders. If equities are supposed to be 60% and drift to 65%, you act. This avoids unnecessary trading when drift is minimal but catches significant drift quickly.

Monthly or more frequent rebalancing is generally not worth it for individual investors. Trading costs and tax implications outweigh the benefits of perfect alignment. The exception: very large portfolios where costs are negligible, or algorithmic systems.

Practical recommendation: Start with annual rebalancing on a fixed date. If you're adding new money regularly (monthly savings or dollar-cost averaging), use that as your rebalance opportunity - redirect new contributions to whichever asset class is underweight. This minimises unnecessary trading while keeping your allocation balanced.

Time-Based vs Threshold-Based: Which Works Better?

Calendar rebalancing (every 12 months) is simple and psychologically satisfying. You commit to a schedule, follow it, and move on. For most people, this is enough.

Threshold rebalancing (e.g., "rebalance when equity allocation drifts beyond 65%") is more responsive. In volatile years, you might rebalance twice; in calm years, maybe not at all. Any edge over calendar rebalancing tends to be small once trading costs are counted.

The catch: threshold-based rebalancing requires discipline. Many investors set a threshold and then ignore it. You're relying on yourself to execute when it's emotionally difficult - selling winners after they've risen. The differences between small-cap and large-cap holdings mean your overall portfolio might drift faster or slower, so understanding your specific holdings helps set realistic thresholds.

Our take: Calendar rebalancing suits most investors. It's mechanical, avoids emotion, and keeps you on schedule. If you have a large portfolio and low-cost trading access, threshold-based rebalancing is a reasonable alternative - but only if you'll actually stick to it.

Tax Efficiency When You Rebalance

Where you hold investments changes the tax impact of rebalancing.

In a tax-free ISA: Rebalance freely. You don't pay Capital Gains Tax on shares held in an ISA, so there's no capital gains tax cost to selling. You can rebalance monthly if you want (though annually is standard). The ISA allowance is £20,000 per tax year in 2026/27, so consider using it before other accounts - you're avoiding tax on future growth, which compounds over decades.

In a pension (SIPP, workplace scheme): Rebalance freely. Growth inside the pension is tax-sheltered. This is one of pensions' underrated benefits - you can rebalance without worrying about capital gains tax.

In a taxable investment account: Here's where it gets tricky. Selling a fund that's risen can trigger capital gains tax. Frequent rebalancing can create unnecessary tax bills. UK investors have an annual Capital Gains Tax allowance, but regular rebalancing can exceed it. Check HMRC's guidance for the current allowance.

Strategy: In taxable accounts, rebalance when you're adding new money. Instead of selling winners, direct new contributions to underweight assets. Over time, this rebalances your portfolio without selling. Only rebalance within the account if the tax bill is justified by significant drift (e.g., drifting from 60/40 to 75/25).

Fund factsheets also tell you whether a fund is an accumulation or income version. Check how each version is taxed in a taxable account before you choose, and keep your rebalancing plan in line with where each fund sits.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is rebalancing actually worth it? Wouldn't I do better just holding my winners?

A: Not necessarily. Holding winners concentrates you in one asset class - usually equities - so your risk keeps rising. Rebalancing can trim returns in strong markets but softens losses in falling ones. You're staying disciplined to your plan, not beating the market.

Q: How do I rebalance if I'm adding money monthly?

A: This is your best rebalancing opportunity. If you're putting £500/month into an ISA and your equities are overweight, put the full £500 into bonds or diversified funds that month. Direct new money to underweight assets - you rebalance without selling or triggering tax.

Q: What if rebalancing means taking a loss? Should I still do it?

A: Usually, yes. If one holding has fallen and you're underweight in it, buying when it's cheaper is what rebalancing enforces. This is how you "buy low" - not timing the market, but following a systematic rule. Your overall investment return can benefit because you're adding to depressed asset classes.

Q: Should I rebalance during a crash?

A: That's often when rebalancing matters most. If equities fall 30% and bonds hold steady, a 60/40 portfolio drifts to roughly 51/49. Rebalancing means selling bonds and buying cheaper equities. It feels terrifying, but it sticks to the "buy low" rule. If you can't stomach this, your target allocation may be too aggressive for your actual risk tolerance.

Q: How much drift is too much before I rebalance?

A: There's no hard rule, but 5 percentage points is a common trigger. If any asset class drifts more than 5 percentage points from its target (e.g., equities from 60% to 65%), that's a signal. If you're doing annual calendar rebalancing, minor drifts under 5 points are fine - just rebalance annually and don't overthink it.

Q: What if I have a pension, ISA, and taxable account? How do I rebalance across all three?

A: Treat them as one portfolio when calculating your allocation. If you're 60% equities and 40% bonds across all three accounts, that's what matters. But rebalance within each tax wrapper separately to minimise tax. If equities are overweight overall, add new money to bonds (in ISA and pension), and only rebalance the taxable account if the tax bill is justified. The compound interest benefit of staying tax-efficient matters more over 20-30 years than any single rebalancing decision.

portfolio rebalancingasset allocationinvestment management