Tax & Business

Cash Basis vs Accrual Accounting for Small Businesses

23 August 2025|SimpleCalc|12 min read
Two accounting methods showing different profit timing

Cash basis and accrual accounting are two fundamentally different ways small businesses record income and expenses. If you're choosing between them - or wondering why your accountant insists on one over the other - the answer comes down to timing: when you record money matters more than you'd think, and it can affect your tax bill, your apparent profit, and how your accounts look to HMRC.

Here's the key difference in 30 seconds: cash basis accounting records income when money arrives and expenses when you pay them. Accrual accounting (which HMRC calls "traditional accounting") records both when they're incurred, regardless of payment timing. For UK small businesses, the choice depends on your business structure, how quickly you get paid and how much bookkeeping you want to do. Let's work through both methods with real numbers so you can see which suits your business.

What Is Cash Basis Accounting?

Under cash basis accounting, you only record transactions when cash moves. An invoice for £500 doesn't count as income until the customer pays you. A supplier bill for £200 doesn't count as an expense until you pay it.

Example: Freelancer on cash basis

You're a freelancer. In January, you invoiced three clients for £1,000 each (£3,000 total). By 31 January, only one client has paid. Your income on cash basis for January is £1,000, not £3,000, because the other two invoices haven't been settled.

In February, the two clients who owed you £2,000 between them finally pay. Now your February income jumps to £2,000 on cash basis - even though you didn't do any new work. Your monthly figures swing depending on when customers pay, not when you earned the money.

This is exactly what cash basis accounting reflects: cash in, cash out, nothing in between.

Advantages:

  • Matches your bank account. Your profit on paper mirrors your actual cash.
  • Simpler to administer. No accruals, prepayments, or complex adjustments.
  • Lower apparent profit in a period where customers owe you money. That can push tax on that income into a later period, which is why some businesses like it.
  • Easier for sole traders and very small businesses with simple finances.

Disadvantages:

  • Gives a distorted picture of profitability. Invoices and bills out of sync mean your "profit" doesn't reflect the actual performance of your business.
  • Seasonal businesses can show wildly different profits month to month even if underlying performance is stable.
  • Doesn't suit businesses with long payment terms (construction, wholesale, etc.).

What Is Accrual Accounting?

Under accrual accounting, you record income when you've earned it and expenses when you've incurred them, regardless of when payment happens. HMRC describes this as recording income and expenses by the date you invoice or are billed.

Example: Same freelancer on accrual basis

Same scenario: three £1,000 invoices in January, but only one paid. On accrual basis, your income for January is £3,000 (the value of work completed), minus any expenses you've incurred, paid or not. The fact that two invoices haven't been paid doesn't reduce your profit figure - the £2,000 is recorded as money owed to you (an asset called receivables).

In February, when those invoices get paid, your profit doesn't change - you already counted the income in January. February shows much smaller profit because you haven't done as much new work.

This gives a truer picture of your business's performance: did you actually complete profitable work, or did you just get paid slowly?

Advantages:

  • Reflects true profitability. Your profit figure shows what you've actually earned and spent.
  • The only option for limited companies and limited liability partnerships, which cannot use cash basis.
  • Matches international standards, making it easier to attract investors or borrow.
  • More informative for business decisions (pricing, staffing, expansion).

Disadvantages:

  • More complex to administer. You need to track receivables, payables, accruals, and prepayments, and HMRC notes it means keeping more records.
  • Can show higher apparent profit than your actual cash position (you might owe the money; your customers might not have paid).
  • Requires stronger bookkeeping discipline and often professional accountancy.

Cash Basis vs Accrual: Side-by-Side

Factor Cash Basis Accrual
Income recorded When paid When earned
Expenses recorded When paid When incurred
Profit matches cash Usually yes Usually no
Admin complexity Low High
Legal requirement Standard for sole traders and partnerships Required for companies and LLPs
Equipment Claimed as an allowable expense (cars via capital allowances) Claimed via capital allowances
Best for Very small sole traders, cash-based services Growing businesses, limited companies

HMRC Rules: Who Can Use Cash Basis?

Cash basis is the standard way to record income and expenses if you're a sole trader or a partnership without corporate partners. You don't have to use it: you can choose traditional (accrual) accounting instead.

Sole traders and partnerships: HMRC's current "who can use cash basis" guidance sets no turnover limit (rules before 6 April 2024 were different, so older articles may quote a threshold). If you opt for traditional accounting, you say so when you send your Self Assessment tax return.

Who cannot use cash basis: limited companies, limited liability partnerships and partnerships with one or more corporate partners. HMRC also excludes some specific cases, including Lloyd's underwriters, farming businesses with a current herd basis election, farming or creative businesses with a profit averaging claim, businesses that have claimed business premises renovation allowance in the previous 7 years, mineral extraction trades and businesses that have ever claimed research and development allowance.

Trusts, charities, and other entities: different rules apply, so check the relevant HMRC guidance or ask an accountant.

Many small businesses choose accrual anyway, especially as they grow, take on longer payment terms or plan to incorporate. If you expect to become a limited company, starting accrual now can be less disruptive than switching later.

Which Should You Choose?

The choice depends on three factors:

1. Your business structure

If you trade as a limited company or LLP, you have no choice - cash basis isn't available. As a sole trader or partnership without corporate partners, cash basis is the standard and traditional accounting is an option you can choose.

2. Your cash flow

If you get paid quickly (retail, cash services, you invoice weekly and get paid in 7 days), cash basis is fine and simpler. Your profit on cash basis will be close to your true profit anyway.

If payment is slow (you invoice, your customer takes 60-90 days), cash basis distorts profit. You'll look unprofitable even when you're performing well. This is especially true in B2B (wholesale, construction, professional services). Accrual is clearer: did you deliver the work? Then you earned the income, and you're taxed on it whether or not the customer has paid yet.

3. Your accountancy cost

Cash basis is cheaper to administer - you and a basic spreadsheet can manage it. Accrual usually needs proper bookkeeping software or an accountant. If you're already paying a bookkeeper £1,000+ per year to maintain accounts, the choice is partly made for you - you might as well use accrual and get proper reports in return.

A common view: if your admin goes beyond "rough numbers in a notepad," accrual is worth considering. It's more work upfront, but it gives better information for business decisions, and you'll avoid the jolt of switching later.

Setting Up Your Accounting System

If you're self-employed and use cash basis, there's nothing extra to opt into. If you use traditional accounting, you need to say so when you send your Self Assessment tax return. If you're a company, your annual accounts are prepared on an accrual basis.

Our Making Tax Digital guide explains the software you'll need and how HMRC expects records to be kept. Both cash and accrual businesses need to record everything - the only difference is when you recognise income and expenses in your accounts.

If you're switching from cash basis to traditional accounting, HMRC says you might have to make some adjustments. These stop income or expenses being counted twice or missed. An accountant can handle this, but it's worth knowing: the switch can make one year's profit look unusually high or low, so keep a clear record of the change and the adjustment.

For businesses with employees, understanding your accounting method also ties into payroll. See our guide on calculating payroll tax for small businesses - whether you're on cash or accrual, payroll tax calculations stay the same, but accrual gives you clearer information on labour costs.

Tax Deductions and Both Methods

One common question: do I get different tax relief on cash vs accrual?

Mostly no. You can claim business tax deductions like professional fees, home office, mileage, and insurance under either method. The timing of when you record the expense differs. The main exception is equipment: on traditional accounting you claim capital allowances on equipment, machinery and vehicles; on cash basis you claim capital allowances only on business cars, and other items you buy and keep for the business are claimed as allowable expenses.

Where timing matters: on accrual, you record the expense when incurred. On cash basis, when paid. If you buy something in one tax year but pay for it in the next, accrual puts it in the first year's accounts; cash basis puts it in the second. That can shift which tax year you claim the relief.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I switch from cash basis to accrual accounting?

A: Yes. You can choose traditional accounting instead and say so on your Self Assessment tax return. You might have to make some adjustments, for example for invoices outstanding at the date of change, to avoid double-counting. Switching mid-year is messy; choose a tax year boundary.

Q: Does my accountant have to prepare accounts in a specific method?

A: If you're a limited company or LLP, accrual is mandatory. As a sole trader or partnership without corporate partners, your accountant can use cash basis, but they might recommend accrual for clarity. Ask them - it depends on your situation.

Q: What if I'm a sole trader and my partner is a company - do we have to use the same method?

A: No. You're separate tax entities. Your partner's company must use accrual. You can stay on cash basis as a sole trader. Talk to an accountant about what makes sense for each business.

Q: Does HMRC prefer cash or accrual?

A: For sole traders and partnerships without corporate partners, HMRC treats cash basis as the standard method and lets you choose traditional accounting instead. Either is acceptable if you're eligible and keep proper records.

Q: I'm invoicing clients but haven't been paid yet. Can I reduce my profit on cash basis to avoid tax?

A: On cash basis, income counts when you actually receive it, so unpaid invoices aren't taxed until they're paid. However, if you're deliberately delaying invoices to manage tax, HMRC might challenge it. When you genuinely did the work and are waiting to be paid, recognising it on receipt is how cash basis works. But if you're artificially deferring invoices or payments, you're in dangerous territory. Use cash basis as intended, not as a tax dodge.

Q: My business is growing fast. Do I have to switch to accrual?

A: Not because of turnover alone: HMRC's current cash basis guidance sets no turnover limit for sole traders and partnerships. You would have to move to accrual if you incorporate as a limited company or LLP, or fall into one of HMRC's excluded categories. If either is likely, talk to your accountant now and get accrual accounts ready in good time.

Q: My VAT-registered - does that change which accounting method I use?

A: No. Your VAT scheme and your income tax accounting method are separate choices. Under standard VAT accounting, you report VAT on your sales and purchase invoices and pay even if invoices are unpaid, which can affect cash flow. The VAT Cash Accounting Scheme (VAT taxable turnover of £1.35 million or less) lets you pay VAT on sales when customers pay you. See our VAT registration guide for more details.

Q: How does depreciation work under cash basis?

A: Depreciation in your accounts isn't what you claim for tax. On cash basis, equipment you buy and keep for the business is claimed as an allowable expense when you pay for it; only business cars go through capital allowances. On traditional accounting, you claim capital allowances on equipment, machinery and vehicles instead. See our depreciation guide for worked examples.

What to Do Next

If you're a sole trader, your accountant (if you have one) will have already chosen a method. If you haven't discussed it, ask them: "Are my accounts on cash basis or traditional accounting?" That one question will clarify your situation.

If you're running your own accounts, choose based on your cash flow and complexity. If invoices sit outstanding for months, accrual gives a clearer picture. If you get paid quickly, cash basis is simpler.

And if you're starting a limited company, use accrual from day one. You're required to, and it's the right choice for a growing business anyway. Our annual investment allowance guide explains how to claim equipment tax relief through capital allowances under traditional accounting.

The right accounting method is mostly about timing rather than paying less tax in the long run. It's about choosing the method that gives you accurate numbers for decisions and keeps you compliant with HMRC. Get it right at the start, and you'll save yourself chaos later.

cash basisaccrual accountingsmall business accounts