Mortgage & Home Buying

Buy-to-Let Mortgage Calculator: Is Your Investment Profitable?

2 September 2025|SimpleCalc|11 min read
Landlord reviewing rental income spreadsheet on tablet

A buy-to-let mortgage is different from a residential mortgage. You're not borrowing to live in the property - you're buying it as an investment, renting it to tenants, and using their rental income (ideally) to cover your mortgage and make a profit. This guide explains how to calculate whether a buy-to-let investment is profitable, using worked numbers and our buy-to-let mortgage calculator to work through the maths.

What Is a Buy-to-Let Mortgage?

A buy-to-let mortgage is a loan secured against a rental property. The key differences from a residential mortgage:

Interest-only is common. Many buy-to-let mortgages are interest-only, meaning you pay interest each month but the capital stays the same. This keeps monthly payments lower, improving your cash flow. On a £200,000 mortgage at 5.2% interest-only, you pay £867/month. On the same mortgage over 25 years repayment, you'd pay £1,193/month - that's £326 more per month that comes straight out of your profit.

Affordability rules are stricter. Residential lenders check whether you can afford the mortgage on your salary. Buy-to-let lenders check whether the rental income covers the mortgage. A typical stress test: they assume interest rates are around 2% higher than your actual rate, then check that the monthly rent covers 125% of the calculated payment. On £200,000 at 5.2% interest-only, that's £867/month. At 7.2% (a +2% stress test), it becomes £1,200/month, so lenders want to see at least £1,500/month in rent. If your property only rents for £1,200, you won't qualify, even if you earn £100,000.

Deposits are usually larger. Residential lenders will go to 95% LTV (5% deposit). Buy-to-let lenders typically cap at 75-80% LTV, meaning you need a 20-25% deposit. On a £200,000 property, that's £40,000-£50,000, not £10,000. Understanding how LTV ratio affects your mortgage rate is crucial - a 65% LTV might be 0.4% cheaper than 75% LTV, saving you thousands over the life of the loan.

Landlord-specific costs matter. Individual landlords cannot deduct residential mortgage interest as an expense (they get a 20% tax reduction instead, see below), and there are many other costs: buildings insurance, maintenance, council tax, letting agent fees, and void periods when the property sits empty. Check out our guide on what counts as income to understand how lenders assess your borrowing capacity.

How to Calculate Rental Yield and Cash Flow

Rental yield sounds simple: divide annual rent by property price. On a £200,000 property renting for £1,200/month (£14,400/year), that's 7.2% gross yield. But that 7.2% is misleading - it's before your mortgage, taxes, and expenses.

Here's the real calculation. Picture this: you're buying a two-bedroom flat in Manchester for £180,000 with a £45,000 deposit (25% deposit, so a £135,000 mortgage at 75% LTV). You get a 5.2% interest-only mortgage over 25 years.

Monthly mortgage payment: £585 Expected rental income: £950/month Gross yield: 6.3% (£950 × 12 ÷ £180,000)

Now subtract the real costs:

  • Mortgage: £585
  • Buildings insurance: ~£40
  • Council tax: ~£100
  • Maintenance & repairs budget: ~£95 (10% of rent)
  • Letting agent fees (if used): ~£95 (10% of rent)
  • Void periods & bad debts: ~£50 (assume 1-2 weeks empty per year)
  • Ground rent / service charge (if flat): ~£30

Total monthly costs: ~£995

Monthly cash flow: £950 - £995 = -£45 per month

You're paying £45/month out of your own pocket, before tax. This is a cash-flow-negative property, even though the rent comfortably covers the mortgage on its own.

Does that mean it's a bad investment? Not necessarily. If the property appreciates 3%/year, you've made money on the price rise. But with interest-only, your monthly payments don't reduce the £135,000 you owe, so any equity gain comes from the price rising, not from the mortgage. You can't run a loss forever - at some point you need the cash flow to turn positive, either by raising rents, refinancing at a lower rate, or cutting costs such as managing the property yourself.

This is why the stress test matters. At a 7.2% stress rate the payment on £135,000 is £810/month, and 125% of that is about £1,013. The £950 rent falls short, so many lenders would not lend on these numbers.

Understanding Buy-to-Let Affordability

Buy-to-let lending is stricter than residential. Here's why lenders impose these rules, and how to navigate them.

The rental income must cover the mortgage at a stress-tested rate. This isn't arbitrary. If you hit a void period (tenant leaves, property sits empty for a month) or interest rates rise, can you keep paying? Lenders want to know the answer is yes. Typical stress test:

  • Assumption 1: Interest rates are around 2% higher than your deal rate (some lenders use more).
  • Assumption 2: The rent covers 120-125% of the stress-tested payment. That buffer accounts for void periods and maintenance.

On a £200,000 interest-only mortgage:

  • Actual rate 5.2%: £867/month
  • Stress-tested rate 7.2%: £1,200/month
  • Rental income needed: £1,200 × 1.25 = £1,500/month

If your property only rents for £1,200/month, you won't get the mortgage, regardless of how much equity you have or how high your salary is.

Some lenders will consider your other income. If you're short on rental income but have a strong salary, a few lenders will let you use employment income to cover the gap. But this is less common and can cost more; most lenders don't accept it.

Your deposit size directly impacts your rate. A 75% LTV might get 5.2%; a 65% LTV might get 4.8%. The difference is 0.4%, or £67/month on a £200,000 interest-only mortgage. If you can stretch to a larger deposit, the rate improvement can be worth it. Read our guide on how much deposit you need to understand the leverage.

Interest-Only vs Repayment for Landlords

This is the big buy-to-let choice, and it's different from buying a home to live in.

Interest-only keeps cash flow positive. On a £200,000 mortgage:

  • Interest-only at 5.2%: £867/month
  • Repayment over 25 years at 5.2%: £1,193/month
  • Difference: £326/month, or £3,911/year

If your property rents for £1,200/month, interest-only gives you room to cover expenses and (barely) break even. Repayment forces you to subsidise the mortgage from your own pocket.

Repayment builds equity faster. With interest-only, you still owe £200,000 in 25 years - the mortgage never shrinks. Understanding mortgage amortisation shows you exactly where each payment goes. With repayment, each payment reduces your balance, so you owe £0 in 25 years. If you can afford it, repayment is safer (you own the property outright eventually) and builds wealth faster.

Some landlords choose interest-only, then switch to repayment later. They start with interest-only to maximise cash flow, then refinance to repayment later in life when their income allows. See whether you should pay off your mortgage or invest to weigh up the long-term strategy.

Tax, Expenses, and Your Real Return

Let's be honest about taxes. Rental profit is taxable income. Your profit is rent minus all allowable expenses.

Income tax on rental profit. You pay tax on rent minus allowable expenses (insurance, repairs, letting agent fees, council tax and more). At the basic rate (20%), if you make £6,000/year profit, you owe £1,200 in tax. At the higher rate (40%), it's £2,400.

Mortgage interest relief (current rules). Landlords get relief on mortgage interest at the basic rate (20%), regardless of their marginal rate. So if you pay £5,000/year in mortgage interest:

  • Basic-rate taxpayer: 20% relief = £1,000 off your tax bill
  • Higher-rate taxpayer: 20% relief = £1,000 off your tax bill (not 40%)

(This was phased in from April 2017 and fully in place from April 2020; before then, higher-rate taxpayers got relief at their full rate. It was a significant tax rise for many landlords.)

National Insurance. Rental income is not employment income, so you don't pay the 8% employee National Insurance on rental profit. Some landlords who are treated as running a business may be able to pay voluntary Class 2 contributions; check HMRC's guidance for your situation.

Real return example. A £180,000 property renting at £950/month:

Item Monthly Annual
Rent £950 £11,400
Mortgage (interest-only at 5.2%) £585 £7,020
Insurance £40 £480
Maintenance £95 £1,140
Letting agent £95 £1,140
Council tax £100 £1,200
Other (voids, bad debts, ground rent) £80 £960
Total outgoings £995 £11,940
Shortfall -£45 -£540

You're negative £540/year before tax. Add appreciation - if the property rises 3% in the first year, that's £5,400 in equity gain. So your total first-year return is about +£4,860, minus capital gains tax when you sell. Over a 10-year hold at 3% a year, the price rise compounds to about £61,900 (before CGT), against about £5,400 of cash shortfall, though nothing guarantees prices rise at all.

HMRC has detailed rules on what counts as an allowable expense - always get an accountant's advice, as rules are technical.

Common Buy-to-Let Mistakes

Not stress-testing your own assumptions. Lenders typically stress-test at around +2% interest. You should stress-test at +3-4%, factor in 4-6 weeks void per year, and budget 15% of rent for maintenance. If it still cash-flows, you've got a safe margin.

Forgetting about landlord-specific costs. You need landlord insurance, not homeowner insurance. You may have to pay council tax in some situations, so check with your local council. In England, landlords must have the electrics checked at least every 5 years by a qualified person. Boiler breakdowns happen. Don't assume "rent covers mortgage" means profit.

Overestimating rent growth. Don't assume rents will rise 5%+ every year. And don't assume you'll always find a tenant willing to pay top market rate; there's friction, void periods, and tenant churn.

Overleveraging. Just because a lender will give you a 75% LTV mortgage doesn't mean you should take it. A larger deposit (65% LTV) gets better rates and lower monthly payments, leaving more room for cash flow. Consider whether you can truly afford the mortgage if rates rise 2-3% further.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I get a buy-to-let mortgage if the rental income doesn't cover the mortgage? A: Most mainstream lenders won't approve it. Some will let you use your own income to cover the gap, but this is less common and can cost more. If the deal doesn't cash-flow on rental income alone, consider a larger deposit (lower LTV) or finding a cheaper property in the same area.

Q: What's the minimum deposit for a buy-to-let? A: Typically 20-25%. Many lenders go to 75% LTV (25% deposit) for standard mortgages. Some lenders will go to 80% LTV (20% deposit), but rates are higher. Understanding how much deposit you need helps you figure out the best strategy for your budget.

Q: Should I choose interest-only or repayment? A: Interest-only gives better cash flow now (lower monthly payment) but leaves you with the full debt in 25 years. Repayment costs more monthly but you own the property outright at the end. Some buy-to-let investors choose interest-only initially, then remortgage to repayment later.

Q: How does buy-to-let mortgage interest get taxed? A: Since April 2020, individual landlords cannot deduct residential mortgage interest as an expense. Instead they get a tax reduction at the basic rate (20%), not their full marginal rate. So a higher-rate taxpayer (40%) only gets 20% relief, not 40%. This reduces your tax advantage compared to the rules before April 2017.

Q: What counts as an allowable expense for tax? A: Buildings and contents insurance, council tax, repairs and maintenance (not improvements), letting agent fees, accountant fees, and utility bills if you pay them. Mortgage interest is not an allowable expense for individual landlords; it gets the 20% tax reduction instead. Capital expenditure (such as a new extension) is not an allowable expense; improvement costs can be deducted from your gain for capital gains tax when you sell. Always get an accountant's advice; the rules are detailed.

Q: Do I need a specialist buy-to-let mortgage broker? A: It helps. Some lenders only work with brokers; others have stricter buy-to-let criteria and a broker will know which ones are most flexible. A good broker can model different deals and find lenders that suit your specifics (large deposit, lower rent, mixed-use property, etc.). It's worth getting quotes from 2-3 brokers plus major lenders direct.

buy to letrental propertylandlord mortgage