Company Car or Car Allowance: Which Saves You More Tax?

Company car or car allowance: which saves you more tax? The answer depends on your salary, the car's value, your driving habits, and how much you're offered in either case. For most UK employees, a car allowance is taxed as regular income, whilst a company car triggers Benefit-in-Kind (BIK) tax instead. One leaves more money in your pocket - but which one is yours?
The Core Difference: Two Paths to a Car
A company car is a vehicle owned by your employer that you're allowed to use for personal driving. You pay income tax on the car's taxable value (the "benefit"), usually collected through your tax code, rather than on cash in your payslip.
A car allowance is cash added to your salary specifically to cover a car. It's taxed as ordinary income - income tax and National Insurance apply - so the amount you actually receive depends on your tax band.
That sounds simple in theory. In practice, the maths is where it gets interesting.
How BIK Tax Works on Company Cars
Benefit-in-Kind tax is calculated on the value of the car - broadly how much it would cost to buy - and the type of fuel it uses. The tax bill depends on:
- The car's value (what it would cost to buy)
- Its CO₂ emissions (lower emissions = lower BIK percentage)
- Your marginal tax rate (20% for basic rate, 40% for higher rate, 45% for additional rate)
- When the car was first registered, which can affect which percentage table applies
HMRC sets a BIK percentage for each band of CO₂ emissions and fuel type, and these percentages change from year to year. Electric vehicles and low-emission plug-in hybrids get much lower percentages than petrol or diesel cars. Use HMRC's company car and fuel benefit calculator to find the current percentage for a specific car.
Worked example: You're offered a company car - a brand-new petrol saloon with a list price of £28,000 and CO₂ emissions of 130g CO₂/km. Suppose the BIK percentage for this car is 23% (check the real figure for the current tax year). That's £28,000 × 23% = £6,440 of taxable benefit per year. If you're a basic-rate taxpayer, that's £6,440 × 20% = £1,288 in tax per year, or £107/month. In this example your employer covers maintenance, insurance, and road tax.
How Car Allowance Tax Works
A car allowance is straightforward: it's added to your gross salary and taxed like any other income.
If your employer offers you a £6,000/year car allowance, that £6,000 is added to your salary. On a basic-rate salary, you pay:
- Income tax: £6,000 × 20% = £1,200
- National Insurance: £6,000 × 8% = £480
- Total deduction: £1,680
You take home £4,320 per year, or £360/month. You then need to buy, insure, and maintain the car yourself - and you can keep any leftover money if you find a cheaper option, or you cover the shortfall if you need something more expensive.
If you're a higher-rate taxpayer (earning over £50,270), the same £6,000 allowance costs you:
- Income tax: £6,000 × 40% = £2,400
- National Insurance: £6,000 × 2% = £120 (the rate on earnings above £50,270)
- Total deduction: £2,520
Take-home: £3,480 per year, or £290/month. The higher your tax band, the more expensive the allowance becomes.
Company Car vs Car Allowance: Direct Comparison
Let's compare these two options head-to-head. Imagine you're offered either (a) a company car or (b) a car allowance of £6,000/year.
The company car option (£28,000 petrol saloon, 23% BIK):
- BIK tax: £1,288/year (basic rate)
- Employer covers: insurance, servicing, road tax, breakdown cover (and sometimes fuel)
- Your cost: £1,288/year
- Fuel: if your employer pays for fuel you use for personal journeys, you pay tax on that separately (the fuel benefit charge)
The car allowance option (£6,000/year, basic rate taxpayer):
- Tax deduction: £1,680/year
- Take-home: £4,320/year
- You buy a car and cover: depreciation, insurance (£600-1,000/year), fuel (£1,200-1,500/year for moderate mileage), servicing (£300-500/year), road tax (£200/year at the standard rate), repairs
For an average car costing £12,000-15,000, depreciation over 5 years is roughly £150-200/month. Add insurance, fuel, servicing and road tax at the figures above, and you're spending roughly £340-470/month before repairs - around or above the £360 net allowance.
This is where the company car often wins. Even though you pay BIK tax, the employer covers most of the running costs, which could cost you as much as or more than the allowance if you self-funded.
But the picture changes if you're a higher-rate taxpayer. Both options cost more. Your BIK tax doubles to £6,440 × 40% = £2,576 a year, while tax and NI on the £6,000 allowance rise to £2,520. In this example the tax on the two options is then almost the same, so the running costs your employer covers become the deciding factor.
When a Car Allowance Makes Sense
There are scenarios where a car allowance beats a company car:
1. You don't need a fancy car. If your employer offers a company car you'd never choose yourself - perhaps a sensible saloon when you'd prefer a modest hatchback - a cash allowance lets you buy what you actually want. A £6,000 allowance could buy a used car outright or via a small personal loan; working out your effective tax rate helps you see the net value.
2. You drive very little. If you work from home 4 days a week and only need a car for occasional commutes, a company car (which you pay BIK tax on all year) may feel expensive compared to an allowance you can stretch across lower mileage. That said, you'd need to use the allowance very efficiently.
3. You want flexibility. A car allowance is yours - you can spend less on a basic car and keep the difference, or spend more and cover the gap from other income. A company car locks you into what the employer provides.
4. You value portability. If you change jobs, a car allowance negotiated into your salary is portable. A company car is tied to that employer. For freelancers or consultants who move between contracts, this matters.
Other Factors to Consider
Fuel and running costs. Company cars with fuel cards remove the weekly surprise at the pump. But if your employer pays for fuel you use for personal journeys, you pay tax on that separately, so check whether the fuel card is worth it for your private mileage. Some employers cap fuel spend (e.g., "we cover up to 8,000 business miles per year") - check the fine print.
Employer pension contributions. When comparing job offers, check whether the car is salary-sacrificed. If you sacrifice £6,000 from gross salary to get a company car, your pension contributions may be calculated on a lower base, which affects your future pension pot. A car allowance doesn't reduce your pension calculation.
Mileage limits. Company cars often come with a mileage expectation (e.g., 12,000/year). Exceed it and you might get no mileage allowance, or a small reimbursement. An allowance has no mileage limit - you can drive as much or little as you want.
Personal tax code. HMRC adjusts your tax code to collect the tax on a company car, and updates it if a change affects the value of the car. The benefit can also matter for benefits or credits you claim. Tell HMRC about changes, such as your employer starting or stopping paying for your private fuel.
Future changes. BIK percentages are set by the government and change over time, including for electric vehicles. If you're offered a company car now, check what the BIK % might be in 3-5 years.
For a detailed look at how your salary is taxed, check out our UK salary after-tax guide, or use our salary calculator to model both scenarios with your actual numbers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I negotiate a car allowance instead of a company car?
Yes. If your employer offers a company car and you'd prefer cash, ask. Employers know it's often cheaper for them to offer a car than to pay salary that covers both the allowance and the tax on it. Be prepared to explain why (mileage, car choice, flexibility) and propose a figure. Many employers are open to this, especially if you're in a negotiating position.
What happens to the BIK tax if I go on parental leave or unpaid leave?
Company car tax is based on the car being available for you to use privately; the taxable value is reduced if you only have it part of the time. If the car stays available to you during leave, expect the tax to continue. Check with your employer or HMRC how a long absence affects your figures.
Do I pay BIK tax on a borrowed company car?
You pay tax if you or your family use a company car privately, including for commuting. Whether occasional use of a shared car counts depends on how it is provided, so check with your employer or HMRC before assuming it is tax-free.
Is a car allowance better if I use my own car for work?
If you use your own car for business journeys, HMRC's approved mileage rate is 55p per mile for the first 10,000 business miles from 6 April 2026 (45p before that), and 25p per mile above 10,000. If your employer pays less than the approved rate, you can get tax relief (Mileage Allowance Relief) on the unused balance. This only works if your employer allows employees to use personal vehicles for business mileage. Clarify with your employer.
What if I'm offered both - a company car AND an allowance?
Some employers offer a company car plus a fuel allowance or road tax allowance as a separate cash sum. Treat the car allowance part as regular income (subject to income tax and NI) and the car as a BIK benefit. The combination might actually be very generous - or it might just be them separating the components. Do the maths for your circumstances.
How does a company car affect my take-home pay compared to a salary increase?
A company car doesn't add cash to your payslip, but the tax on it is usually collected through your tax code, so your take-home pay falls by the BIK tax. It also affects your taxable income, which can matter for benefits, credits, or future salary thresholds. A salary increase is usually more flexible. See how salary increases actually work for more detail.
What about salary sacrifice schemes for cars?
Some employers offer salary-sacrifice car schemes where you sacrifice gross salary to "buy" a company car (which you don't actually own; it's a long-term lease). Salary sacrifice cars have their own tax rules, so ask your employer for the after-tax figures. It can also reduce your pension base. Compare: BIK tax on a straight company car vs. the after-tax cost of the salary sacrifice, minus the pension reduction.
Should I try to negotiate a higher salary instead of a car benefit?
Possibly. Run the numbers both ways. If you'd rather have complete flexibility and don't care about a car, push for salary. If a car is important and you'd buy one anyway, accepting a company car or modest allowance often costs you less tax than the salary equivalent. Our salary calculator lets you model both.
The Bottom Line
For many employees, a company car works out cheaper than a car allowance once running costs are included. In our example, BIK tax is £1,288 a year for a basic-rate taxpayer (£2,576 at higher rate), while tax and NI on a £6,000 cash allowance is £1,680 (£2,520 at higher rate). Plus, the employer covers insurance and servicing.
But a car allowance wins if you don't need an expensive car, drive very little, or want complete flexibility in what you drive and how much you spend.
The deciding factor is almost always the numbers for your specific situation. If you're comparing job offers, plug both scenarios into our salary calculator - enter your gross salary with a company car and then with a car allowance, and see which gives you the highest take-home pay. Then factor in the non-tax stuff: do you like the car on offer? Will you actually drive it? Do you need the flexibility of an allowance?
Make the choice that works for your life, not just the spreadsheet. But definitely do the spreadsheet first.